Publication Ethics

1. Publication Ethics Statement

JUPE: Jurnal Pendidikan Mandala, published by Lembaga Penelitian dan Pendidikan (LPP) Mandala, is committed to maintaining academic integrity, transparency, fairness, and accountability throughout the scholarly publishing process. This Publication Ethics policy applies to authors, editors, reviewers, the publisher, and other parties involved in manuscript evaluation and publication.

The journal's ethical principles take into account the Code of Ethics for Scientific Publication established by Regulation of the Head of the Indonesian Institute of Sciences (LIPI) Number 5 of 2014, together with internationally recognized principles of responsible scholarly publishing, including relevant guidance from the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE).

JUPE upholds three fundamental principles of publication ethics:

  1. Neutrality: Editorial and publication decisions must be free from improper conflicts of interest and undue influence.

  2. Fairness: Authorship, editorial treatment, peer review, and publication decisions must be conducted fairly and objectively.

  3. Honesty: Research and publication must be free from plagiarism, duplication, fabrication, falsification, and other forms of academic misconduct.

The journal is committed to protecting the integrity of the scholarly record and promoting responsible research and publication practices in education.

2. Responsibilities of the Publisher

LPP Mandala is responsible for supporting the journal's editorial independence and maintaining ethical and transparent publication practices. The publisher shall:

  1. Support the editorial team in implementing the journal's publication policies and ethical standards.

  2. Ensure that the journal's policies concerning peer review, publication fees, copyright, licensing, and access to published content are publicly available.

  3. Ensure that publication fees do not influence editorial decisions concerning manuscript acceptance or rejection.

  4. Support fair investigations into allegations of publication misconduct.

  5. Cooperate with the editorial team in implementing appropriate corrections, expressions of concern, retractions, and other measures necessary to preserve the integrity of published research.

  6. Maintain clear official communication channels for authors, reviewers, readers, and other stakeholders.

The publisher shall respect editorial independence and shall not improperly interfere with the evaluation of individual manuscripts.

3. Responsibilities of Editors

Editors are responsible for ensuring that submitted manuscripts are evaluated fairly, objectively, confidentially, and in accordance with the journal's aims and scope.

Editors shall:

  1. Assess manuscripts according to their relevance to education, originality, scholarly contribution, methodological soundness, clarity, and compliance with publication requirements.

  2. Make editorial decisions based on academic merit rather than the authors' nationality, ethnicity, gender, religion, institutional affiliation, personal relationships, or financial circumstances.

  3. Ensure that manuscripts undergo the journal's established peer-review process.

  4. Select qualified reviewers whose expertise is relevant to the manuscript and who can provide independent assessments.

  5. Maintain the confidentiality of submitted manuscripts, reviewer reports, editorial correspondence, and unpublished information.

  6. Avoid using unpublished information from submitted manuscripts for personal research or professional advantage without the appropriate authorization.

  7. Investigate suspected plagiarism, duplicate publication, fabrication, falsification, authorship misconduct, and other potential breaches of publication ethics.

  8. Provide authors with clear editorial decisions and relevant reviewer feedback, where appropriate.

  9. Consider and respond to complaints, appeals, and credible allegations of misconduct in a fair and timely manner.

  10. Initiate appropriate post-publication action when errors or ethical violations materially affect the reliability or integrity of a published article.

  11. Recuse themselves from handling manuscripts when a conflict of interest could compromise their impartiality and arrange for an independent editor to handle the manuscript where practicable.

Final editorial decisions remain the responsibility of the journal's editors and are made after considering the available evidence, peer-review reports, and the manuscript's scholarly quality.

4. Responsibilities of Reviewers

JUPE applies a double-blind peer-review process in which the identities of authors and reviewers are concealed from one another during the review process. Submitted research articles are evaluated by at least two expert reviewers, as stated in the journal's Peer Review Process policy.

Reviewers are expected to:

  1. Provide objective, constructive, and evidence-based assessments of the manuscript's originality, relevance, methodology, analysis, interpretation, and contribution to educational scholarship.

  2. Evaluate the manuscript in accordance with the journal's focus and scope.

  3. Treat manuscripts, reviewer reports, and all non-public information obtained during peer review as confidential.

  4. Decline review assignments when they lack the necessary expertise, cannot complete the review within a reasonable period, or have a conflict of interest.

  5. Identify relevant publications that have not been cited and inform the editor of substantial similarities with other works or possible ethical concerns.

  6. Avoid personal criticism, discriminatory comments, inappropriate language, and requests for citations that do not have a legitimate scholarly justification.

  7. Refrain from using unpublished manuscript content for personal or professional purposes without authorization.

  8. Disclose actual or potential conflicts of interest to the editor before proceeding with the review.

Reviewers provide recommendations to support editorial decisions but do not independently determine whether a manuscript will be published.

Reviewers must not upload confidential manuscripts or reviewer materials to public generative artificial intelligence services or use such services in a manner that compromises manuscript confidentiality.

5. Responsibilities of Authors

Authors submitting manuscripts to JUPE are responsible for ensuring the integrity, originality, accuracy, and ethical acceptability of their work.

5.1. Originality and Plagiarism

Authors must submit original scholarly work and appropriately acknowledge all ideas, findings, quotations, data, and materials derived from other sources.

Plagiarism in any form is unacceptable, including direct copying without attribution, inappropriate paraphrasing, and the presentation of another person's work or ideas as one's own.

JUPE uses Turnitin as part of its manuscript similarity-screening process. Similarity reports are evaluated in context by the editorial team, taking into account quotations, references, common terminology, and other relevant factors. A similarity score alone does not establish whether plagiarism has occurred.

5.2. Duplicate and Simultaneous Submission

Authors must not submit the same manuscript simultaneously to multiple journals.

Manuscripts that have already been published in substantially the same form must not be presented as original unpublished work. Redundant publication and inappropriate text recycling are unacceptable.

Any overlap with previously disseminated research, including preprints or related publications, must be disclosed when relevant so that the editor can assess its acceptability under the journal's policies.

5.3. Data Fabrication and Falsification

Authors must report their research honestly and accurately.

Data fabrication, data falsification, manipulation of research results, misleading reporting, and the deliberate omission or alteration of evidence to support predetermined conclusions constitute serious ethical violations.

Authors must ensure that the research findings, tables, figures, analysis, and conclusions are supported by the underlying evidence.

5.4. Authorship and Contributorship

Authorship must be based on substantial scholarly or intellectual contributions to the research, analysis, interpretation, or preparation of the manuscript.

All listed authors must approve the final version of the manuscript, agree to its submission to JUPE, and accept responsibility for the integrity of their contributions.

Gift authorship, guest authorship, ghost authorship, and the omission of legitimate contributors are unacceptable.

The corresponding author is responsible for ensuring that all co-authors approve the manuscript and are informed of important editorial decisions.

Changes to the author list after submission must be justified and approved by all affected authors, subject to the editor's assessment.

Artificial intelligence tools cannot be listed as authors or co-authors.

5.5. Citation and Acknowledgment

Authors must accurately cite relevant scholarly sources and ensure that all in-text citations correspond to entries in the reference list.

References must be relevant to the claims they support. Fabricated references, knowingly inaccurate citations, and citation manipulation are unacceptable.

Individuals, institutions, and organizations that have contributed to the research but do not qualify for authorship should be acknowledged appropriately.

5.6. Research Funding and Conflicts of Interest

Authors must disclose relevant financial and non-financial interests that could reasonably be perceived as influencing the research or its interpretation.

All applicable research funding sources and relevant sponsor involvement must be acknowledged.

Where no relevant conflict of interest exists, authors should provide an explicit declaration to that effect.

5.7. Research Ethics and Protection of Participants

Research involving human participants, including students, teachers, school personnel, parents, and other educational stakeholders, must comply with applicable legal requirements, institutional policies, and relevant ethical standards.

Where required, authors must obtain approval from an appropriate research ethics committee or institutional review body before conducting the research. Informed consent must be obtained when applicable.

Research involving minors must provide appropriate safeguards, including parental or guardian consent and participant assent where required. Authors must protect the privacy, confidentiality, dignity, and welfare of research participants.

Authors must not disclose personally identifiable student information, confidential school records, or other sensitive research materials without proper authorization and an appropriate legal or ethical basis.

Any required ethical approval, consent procedures, and relevant safeguards should be reported in the manuscript.

5.8. Research Data and Reproducibility

Authors are responsible for maintaining the integrity of their research records and supporting evidence.

Where appropriate, authors should describe the data sources, instruments, analytical procedures, and methodological decisions necessary to understand and assess the research.

Supporting data or documentation may be requested by the editor when reasonably necessary to investigate a concern or assess the reliability of the reported findings, subject to applicable ethical, legal, confidentiality, and data-protection requirements.

Authors are encouraged to provide a data availability statement where relevant.

5.9. Use of Artificial Intelligence

Authors remain fully responsible for the accuracy, originality, integrity, and scholarly validity of their submitted manuscripts, including content produced with generative artificial intelligence tools.

AI tools must not be listed as authors. Where AI tools have materially contributed to writing, analysis, coding, image generation, or other substantive aspects of the research or manuscript preparation, authors must disclose the tool used and the nature of its contribution in an appropriate section or disclosure statement.

Authors must verify AI-assisted information, references, factual claims, calculations, and interpretations before submission. Fabricated references, false data, misleading results, plagiarism, and manipulation of research evidence are prohibited regardless of whether AI tools were involved.

Authors must also ensure that the use of AI does not violate privacy, confidentiality, intellectual property rights, or research ethics requirements.

6. Peer Review and Editorial Decisions

JUPE evaluates submitted manuscripts through editorial screening and double-blind peer review.

The editorial team initially assesses whether a submission is relevant to the journal's focus and scope, follows the author guidelines, and meets basic scholarly and ethical requirements. Manuscripts that do not meet these requirements may be returned for correction or rejected before external review.

Research articles proceeding to peer review are evaluated by at least two expert reviewers. Reviewers are expected to assess the scholarly quality and provide recommendations for improvement.

The editor considers the reviewer reports and the manuscript's overall merit when deciding whether to accept, request revision, or reject a submission. Reviewer recommendations inform the decision but do not replace editorial responsibility.

The journal may screen submitted manuscripts for similarity using Turnitin. Suspected plagiarism or other ethical concerns may result in additional assessment and appropriate editorial action.

Publication fees do not guarantee acceptance and must not influence the outcome of peer review.

7. Conflicts of Interest

All parties involved in the publication process must disclose actual or potential conflicts of interest that could compromise, or reasonably be perceived to compromise, their impartiality.

Authors must disclose relevant financial and non-financial interests. Reviewers must inform the editor of circumstances that could affect their objectivity. Editors must not handle manuscripts in which personal, professional, financial, or other relationships could compromise independent decision-making.

Where a conflict is identified, appropriate measures may include reassignment to an independent editor or selection of another reviewer.

8. Handling Allegations of Publication Misconduct

JUPE does not tolerate plagiarism, duplicate or redundant publication, fabrication, falsification, inappropriate authorship, citation manipulation, or other serious breaches of publication ethics.

Allegations of misconduct may arise from editorial screening, peer review, published research, or reports submitted by authors, readers, institutions, or other interested parties.

When a credible concern is identified, the editorial team shall assess the available evidence fairly and confidentially. The authors concerned may be asked to provide an explanation, original data, research documentation, or other relevant information.

Appropriate actions depend on the nature and seriousness of the suspected violation and may include:

  1. Requesting clarification or correction from the authors.

  2. Rejecting a manuscript that does not meet the journal's ethical standards.

  3. Requesting correction of a published article where appropriate.

  4. Publishing an expression of concern or retracting an article when justified by the evidence.

  5. Referring the matter to the relevant institution or authority where warranted.

The journal shall handle allegations impartially and provide relevant parties with an appropriate opportunity to respond. Confidentiality shall be maintained to the extent practicable, subject to the requirements of a fair investigation.

9. Complaints and Appeals

Authors, reviewers, readers, and other interested parties may submit complaints concerning editorial decisions, peer review, authorship, conflicts of interest, research integrity, or publication ethics.

Complaints and appeals should be submitted through the journal's official OJS communication channel or the official editorial contact published on the journal website. The submission should identify the relevant article or manuscript and provide a clear explanation and supporting information.

The editor shall assess complaints objectively and confidentially. Where a complaint concerns an editor or another person directly involved in the matter, an independent person should be assigned to assess it where practicable.

Appeals against editorial decisions may be considered when they identify a material procedural error, relevant new evidence, or a substantive misunderstanding that could affect the decision. Disagreement with an editorial assessment alone does not automatically justify reversal.

The journal shall communicate the outcome of its assessment to the relevant parties when appropriate.

10. Corrections, Expressions of Concern, and Retractions

JUPE is committed to preserving the accuracy and integrity of the scholarly record.

When an error in a published article is identified, the editorial team shall assess its significance and determine whether a correction or another appropriate notice is necessary.

An expression of concern may be issued when credible concerns about a publication remain unresolved and readers need to be informed while further assessment is undertaken.

Retraction may be considered when reliable evidence demonstrates that an article's findings are substantially unreliable, the article involves serious research or publication misconduct, or another compelling reason undermines the integrity of the published record.

Decisions concerning corrections and retractions shall be based on the available evidence and the seriousness of the issue. Authors should be given an appropriate opportunity to respond where practicable.

Correction and retraction notices should identify the affected article and explain the reason for the action. The journal should maintain a clear connection between the original publication and any related notice so that readers can understand the status of the article.

The purpose of these actions is to correct the scholarly record and protect the reliability of published research.

11. Copyright, Licensing, and Publication Fees

JUPE's copyright and licensing arrangements are described in the journal's Copyright Notice and Open Access Policy. Under the stated policy, articles are published under the Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International license (CC BY-SA 4.0).

Authors and other parties must respect the applicable copyright, attribution, and licensing requirements when reusing published material.

The journal's Article Processing Charge (APC) is stated as IDR 500,000 and is payable after an article has been accepted for publication, in accordance with the journal's fee policy.

Payment of the APC does not guarantee acceptance or influence the academic evaluation of a manuscript. Editorial decisions must remain independent of financial considerations.

Authors should use the journal's official OJS system and official communication channels for submission-related correspondence and publication payments. Communications or payment requests from unauthorized parties should be verified with the journal before any action is taken.

12. Confidentiality and Privacy

Manuscripts, reviewer reports, editorial correspondence, and non-public research information must be handled confidentially throughout the publication process.

Such information must not be disclosed to unauthorized parties or used for personal or professional advantage.

Personal information submitted through the journal website shall be handled in accordance with the journal's Privacy Statement and applicable data-protection requirements.

Confidential information may be disclosed when required for a legitimate ethical investigation or by applicable law, with appropriate safeguards.

13. Implementation of the Publication Ethics Policy

All authors, editors, reviewers, and other parties involved in the publication process are expected to comply with this Publication Ethics policy.

The editorial team and publisher are responsible for communicating the policy, applying it consistently, and reviewing it periodically to maintain alignment with developments in scholarly publishing and relevant ethical standards.

This policy should be read together with the journal's Author Guidelines, Peer Review Process, Copyright Notice, Open Access Policy, Article Processing Charge, and Privacy Statement.

Policy framework: Regulation of the Head of the Indonesian Institute of Sciences (LIPI) Number 5 of 2014 concerning the Code of Ethics for Scientific Publication; relevant COPE guidance; and the Principles of Transparency and Best Practice in Scholarly Publishing developed by COPE, DOAJ, OASPA, and WAME.